I would really suggest seeing "All Shook Up"! I wasn't expecting the show to be so great, but it was fantastic. I've seen it three times and would love to see it more! The whole cast is extremely talented - especially the oh-so-hot Cheyenne and the adorable Jenn! It's a shame a lot of people don't see it because it's a "jukebox" musical - I admit I was weary at first, but it seriously became one of my favorite musicals. (Even if you're not a big Elvis fan, the song arrangements are amazing!)
Not to mention that Cheyenne's hotness is worth the whole ticket price!

But, seriously, I love this show.
They are also the nicest cast on Broadway, so I would totally suggest stage-dooring, too!